Telephone: (906) 842-3366

Email: : info@fishtalesup.com
Open : Seasonal
Our Menu

Our Menu

***

pricing is subject to change without notice

Burgers

Add a Side 2.50

Finnish Logger10.00

Grilled Mushrooms, Crispy Bacon, Fried Onion Tanglers & Melted Swiss Cheese Atop a 1/3 lb....

Badass11.00

1/3 lb. Herford Beef Patty, 1/3 lb. Fried Macaroni & Cheese, Crispy Bacon, Provolone  &...

Forest Fire9.00

Maple Sriracha Glazed 1/3 lb. Patty Topped with Jalapenos,  Pepper Jack Cheese & Scallions  

Your Way6.50

1/3 lb. of Hand Pattied Herford Beef Cooked to Order & Served on a Toasted...

Carryout Chicken

Moist & Tender Chicken, Fries & Coleslaw

Dinners

Served with Soup or Garden Salad, & Choice of Side

Crab Crusted Poor Man’s Lobster14.00

Whitefish Baked with Butter & Savory Seasonings, then Topped with Our Crab Parmesan Stuffing  

Filet of Beef18.00

Choice Beef Tenderloin Char-Grilled to Order, Served Over Garlic Toast with Au Jus on the...

Northwoods 1/2 Chicken16.00

Jumbo Marinated Breast, Thigh, Leg & Wing, Fried to Perfection & Served with Maple Sriracha,...

Pan Fried Walleye18.00

Lightly Breaded, Pan Fried to a Golden Brown & Served with Lemon & Tartar Sauce...

Sandwiches

Add a Side 2.50

Meatloaf Stacker13.00

Thick Cut Grilled Garlic Toast Topped with a Generous Portion of Homemade Meatloaf, Redskin Mashed...

Mega BLT10.00

½ lb. Thick Cut Crispy Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato & Mayo Stacked Three Layers High on...

Tenderloin Steak Sandwich14.00

Seared Tenderloin Tips, Grilled Mushrooms  & Fried Onion Tanglers Served Atop Thick Cut Grilled Garlic...

Badass Fish Sandwich11.00

1/3 lb. Panko Fried Whitefish, 1/3 lb. Fried Macaroni & Cheese, Bacon, American & Provolone...

Chicken Strips8.00

Four Crispy Chicken Strips Served with Garlic Toast & Your Choice of Maple Sriracha, Buffalo,...

Pork Tenderloin Sandwich10.00

One Very Large Portion of Pork Schnitzel Served on a Grilled Hoagie with Lettuce, Tomato...

Mushroom Philly9.00

Shaved Prime Rib, Grilled Mushrooms, Green Peppers & Onions Smothered in Melted Swiss & American...

Fish Tacos9.00

Lightly Breaded Pan Fried Whitefish Topped with Sweet Asian Slaw, Spicy Chipotle Ranch & Pico...

Soup & Salad

Add a Grilled Chicken Breast 3.00

Raspberry Harvest Salad8.00

Lettuce Topped with, Red Onions, Bleu Cheese, Cranberries, Candied Walnuts & Raspberry Vinaigrette  

Fajita Salad8.00

Crisp Greens, Pico De Gallo, Made to Order Tortilla Chips, Cheddar Jack Cheese & Chipotle...

Classic Garden Side Salad4.00

Iceberg Lettuce, Tomato, Red Onions, Croutons & Shredded Parmesan  

Wisconsin Beer & Cheese SoupCup 4.00 Bowl 6.00

Starters

Stuffed Mushrooms10.00

Fresh Button Mushrooms, Garlic Butter & Our Crab Parmesan Stuffing Broiled to a Golden Brown...

Cheese Curds8.00

Wisconsin Cheese Curds Lightly Dusted with Seasoned Flour; Fried to Perfection & Served with Ranch...

Black & Bleu Steak Bites14.00

Seared Tenderloin Tips Over a Bed of Fried Onion Tanglers & Broiled Topped with Bleu...

Clam Strips8.00

½ lb. of Fried Clam Strips Served with Sweet Chili Sauce  

Mozzarella Wontons8.00

Mozzarella Cheese & Pepperoni Wrapped in Crispy Wontons & Served with Marinara Sauce  

Quesadillas8.00 / Chicken 11.00

Sautéed Onions & Green Peppers, Chipotle Ranch & Cheddar Jack Cheese Served Inside Grilled Flour...

Battered Green Beans9.00

Green Beans Lightly Battered, Fried & Served with Ranch  

Chicken Wings or Drummies9.00 / 11.00

One Pound of Fried Chicken Wings or Jumbo Chicken Drummies Served Plain, or Glazed with...

Top↑